← Back to arXiv
arXivLogicarXiv:2607.13327

The Constant Domain Axiom in Toposes

The paper explores a particular version of intuitionistic logic called "constant domain" logic, which is a form of reasoning that sits between classical logic (where every statement is either true or false) and full intuitionistic logic (which is more cautious about what counts as proven). The "constant domain" part means that the collection of objects you are reasoning about stays fixed and does not vary depending on context, even though truth values can still behave in a non-classical way. The paper looks at how to give a rigorous mathematical meaning to this kind of logic using structures called toposes, which are generalized mathematical universes that can model various logical systems.

The key technical move is to identify which objects inside a topos behave like genuine "constant" collections of things. The authors argue that the right way to characterize these objects is through two properties borrowed from topology: being "covert" (a compactness-like condition) and being "Hausdorff" (a separation condition ensuring points can be told apart). Objects satisfying both conditions are called "CD objects." This is a more conceptually satisfying explanation than previous approaches, which simply declared certain objects to be constant by hand without explaining what made them special from the perspective of the surrounding mathematical universe.

The main result is that CD objects, across any topos, fit together into a well-behaved mathematical structure called a Boolean pretopos. Roughly, this means the CD objects form a coherent universe of their own that obeys classical logic, even when the surrounding topos does not. This confirms the intuition that constant domain logic is a middle ground: the objects being reasoned about behave classically, but the logical framework around them remains intuitionistic. The paper thus clarifies and tidies up the foundations of constant domain logic by grounding it firmly in topos theory.

Read original →