A smooth real algebraic curve of degree four, called a quartic, can form various patterns of closed loops (called ovals) in the real projective plane. A long-standing area of study in real algebraic geometry asks which combinatorial arrangements of such curves, relative to other geometric objects, can actually be realized by true algebraic equations. This paper focuses on how a quartic curve can be positioned relative to three lines, under the specific condition that every oval of the quartic crosses at least one of the three lines. The goal is to produce a complete list of which such arrangements are possible.
The classification was partially completed in earlier work by Maletto, and the present paper finishes the job. The authors determine precisely which arrangements can be realized by genuine algebraic curves defined by polynomial equations, and which can be realized only by the broader class of pseudoholomorphic curves, which satisfy a more flexible geometric condition. The key finding is that there is exactly one arrangement that a pseudoholomorphic quartic can achieve relative to three lines but that no algebraic quartic can replicate, revealing a genuine gap between the two settings.
The authors also show how this exotic arrangement can be constructed using a technique called combinatorial patchworking, which is a method for building curves by gluing together simple pieces according to a triangulation of a polygon. Normally, patchworking on a standard regular triangulation is known to produce algebraically realizable curves, but here the construction uses an irregular triangulation and yields a piecewise-linear curve whose arrangement is algebraically forbidden. This is the first known example where combinatorial patchworking on an irregular triangulation produces a curve whose positioning relative to the coordinate axes cannot be matched by any algebraic curve, making it a noteworthy result for the field.