← Back to arXiv
arXivCombinatoricsarXiv:2608.02667

Large Sidon Subsets of Distinct Multinomial Coefficients

The paper studies a special collection of numbers built from a positive integer n. Specifically, you take n factorial and divide it by the product of factorials of numbers that add up to n. These are called multinomial coefficients, and for a given n there are many distinct values they can take. The authors are interested in finding large "Sidon subsets" within this collection. A Sidon set is a set of numbers where all pairwise sums are distinct, meaning no two different pairs of elements add up to the same value. Sidon sets appear naturally in combinatorics and number theory, and understanding how large they can be inside a structured set of numbers is a central question here.

The main results push in two directions. On the positive side, the authors show that the maximum size of a Sidon subset grows faster than linearly in n, specifically at least as fast as n times the logarithm of n, with a more precise bound involving an exponential of a square root of the logarithm. They achieve this through a combination of tools: a structural lemma about "strongly Sidon" subsets, known results about Sidon sets in general, and facts about partitions of integers into prime parts. On the negative side, they show that a substantial portion of the full collection cannot be squeezed into any Sidon subset, by constructing many non-overlapping arithmetic progressions inside the collection. Arithmetic progressions are inherently hostile to Sidon sets because they generate repeated pairwise sums.

To complement the theoretical work, the authors also computed exact answers for small values of n up to 16 using a SAT solver, which is a computational tool that efficiently searches through logical constraints. This required encoding the Sidon condition as a satisfiability problem and running exhaustive searches. The paper includes the full source code and output for the hardest cases, making the computational results fully reproducible. Together, the theoretical bounds and computational data paint a detailed picture of how large Sidon subsets of multinomial coefficients can be.

Read original →