← Back to arXiv
arXivCombinatoricsarXiv:2608.04040

The Havel--Hakimi Residue of Common-Divisor Graphs: Resolving and Extending a Problem of Graffiti and Erd\H{o}s

The paper studies a specific family of graphs built from the integers 2 through n, where two numbers are connected by an edge if they share a common factor greater than 1. So for example, 6 and 10 are connected because they share the factor 2, but 4 and 9 are not connected because their only common factor is 1. The object of study is a quantity called the Havel-Hakimi residue, which is a number you get by running a specific algorithm on the list of how many neighbors each vertex has. This residue is interesting because it gives a lower bound on the size of the largest independent set in a graph, meaning the largest collection of numbers in your set that share no common factors with each other.

The main result resolves a conjecture going back to Erdos and a mathematician named Staton, which predicted the precise rate at which this residue grows as n gets large. The answer involves a famous constant called zeta(2), which equals pi squared over 6, and the growth rate is roughly proportional to n divided by the logarithm of n. The authors not only confirm this leading behavior but also pin down the next correction term, giving a much sharper picture. The key insight is that prime numbers play a special role: primes only connect to multiples of themselves, so they tend to sit in relatively isolated positions in the graph, and analyzing their contribution carefully using classical results about the distribution of primes drives the proof.

The paper also has an unusual methodological dimension. Part of the work was guided by an AI-assisted conjecturing system called Theo-Conjecture, which operates under human supervision and uses computational experiments to generate and refine guesses, some of which were later turned into rigorous theorems. The authors present this as a worked example of how automated conjecture-making can interact productively with traditional mathematical proof. They close by stating a new open problem suggested by computation: that the Havel-Hakimi residue is almost always within 2 of a simpler related quantity, a clean and testable conjecture left for future work.

Read original →