The paper investigates special collections of functions called "maximal eventually different families," or MED families. Roughly speaking, a MED family is a set of infinite sequences of natural numbers where no two sequences agree too often past any given point, and the family is as large as possible in the sense that no new sequence can be added while preserving that property. The "maximality" condition can be made more flexible by introducing an ideal, which is a notion of which sets of natural numbers count as negligible. The paper studies several different ways of defining this maximality and asks how complex these families can be in a descriptive set-theoretic sense, meaning how difficult they are to describe or construct in a precise mathematical hierarchy ranging from simple Borel sets up through analytic and beyond.
A central theme is understanding when these families can be built in a "nice" or low-complexity way. The paper shows that one version of maximality, called Van Douwen maximality, turns out to be equivalent to a related but distinct combinatorial condition involving pairs of ideals. For several well-known ideals, this equivalence rules out the existence of analytically definable Van Douwen families entirely. The paper also introduces and compares several notions of "productivity," which capture how well a MED family interacts with product-like operations. One of these notions, called finite-section productivity, turns out to connect naturally to ultrafilters, which are idealized notions of "largeness" for sets of natural numbers, and the connection can be visualized geometrically through a topological space called the Stone space.
On the constructive side, the paper builds explicit Borel-definable families satisfying the various productivity conditions, under appropriate assumptions on the ideal involved. However, it also establishes sharp limits: for the most classical ideal of finite sets, no analytically definable family can satisfy finite-section productivity. For Ramsey ultrafilters, a particularly well-behaved class, no analytic MED family of the relevant type exists at all. Yet under a strong set-theoretic assumption called the axiom of constructibility, a Ramsey ultrafilter exists for which a slightly more complex, co-analytic MED family can be found. Together, these results map out a detailed and nuanced landscape of what is and is not achievable at different levels of descriptive complexity.